Go to the home page of Electric Scotland Read about our terms and conditions for using te site and out privacy policy Gte our contact information here Find accommodation in Scotland Get information on Scottish agriculture and wildlife Find hundreds of historical articles about Scotland Beth's monthly publication about the Scots diaspora and genealogy Hundreds of online books for you to read Learn something about business in Scotland We have some 800 children's stories for you to read This is where you'll learn all about Scottish clans and families and their history Learn about Scottish culture and also our old Scots language A collection of material from a native Indian writer on Indian lore, poems, recipes and lots more This is Alastair's personal site with his travel journals and loads of pictures taken on his travels in Scotland and abroad Hundreds of biographies of famous Scots A weekly publication from the Scots Independent Newspaper on matters to do with Scottish independence This is where you can message with others on any topic you wish and interact in a social network Great place to get those great Scottish recipes We do need some relaxation from time to time so enjoy some of our online games This is our six volume gazetteer of Scotland Get advice and resources to help with your genealogy research Learn all about Scotland's famous Haggis Learn about prevntative health care from old Scottish texts This is where we've profiled some Highland Games in Scotland and around the world Explore historic places and castles in Scotland Tons of information on the history of Scotland and the Scots Looing for a wee humour or humor story then enjoy our great collection here Poems and stories from the pen of John Henderson and also many of his own dorric poems Lots of interesting material for kids and children of all ages A bit of a catch all for things that don't have there own menu Some music and radio programs for you to listen to and lots of great sheet music Get up to date Scottish news and find all the local newspaper and television stations This is where you can read Electric Scotland's weekly newsletter and read back copies We have thousands of pictures of Scotland and this page will lead you to them We have lots of poetry and stories sent in by visitors to the site Send a postcard to friends, family or colleagues Yes the Bible but so much more Learn about Scotland's famous bard Robert Burns Learn about the Scots who moved to Ulster and onto the world Scotland's official langiuage for several centuries wasn't gaelic but Scots! Learn about the famous Scottish and Highland regiments Some useful services like a roman numeral calculator and personal worth Here you will find our own shopping malls Looking for those old Scots songs then this is where you'll find them History of sports in Scotland Learn about tartan and use the tartan search engines Travel and Tourism in Scotland Some interesting Scottish trivia to baffle your friends with Fun videos that we've taken over the years A Scottish wedding guide Find out the last 100 items we've added to the site Learn about what Scots did in the world Learn about Scots in the USA Learn about Scots in Canada Learn about Scots in Australia Learn about Scots in India Learn about Scots in Germany Learn about Scots in France Learn about Scots in New Zealand

Check all the Clans that have DNA Projects. If your Clan is not in the list there's a way for it to be listed.Edinburgh and Scotland Accommodation, Bed & Breakfast, Self Catering, Guest Houses, Inns, Holiday Tourist AccommodationAn amazing collection of unique holiday cottages, castles and apartments, all over Scotland in truly amazing locations.A comprehensive holiday accommodation Index for Scotland

Click here to get a Printer Friendly Page
Scots Place Names
Buy MacSweens haggis and Grants tinned haggis online from the Scottish Haggis Store
Buy Scottish Hampers, Christmas Hampers, Corporate Food and Gift Hampers from The Scottish Store
Advertise on all 1000+ pages of the Flag in the Wind
Handmade Gifts

 

Scots Independent

The Flag in the Wind
Features - Talking Independence

 Scottish Flag

Home | About Us | Subscriptions | Archives | SNP | Ad Rates | Features | Adverts | Events | Links

Scotland pays her way - and more

Can Scotland stand on her own two feet?

Scotland is very well placed to be a powerhouse economy. We already have a larger economy than many other countries like Norway, Finland, Ireland, and New Zealand. Not many countries in Europe can rival our wealth of natural resources and our educated workforce. Scotland:

  • has the EU's 4th biggest financial centre

  • has three quarters of the EU's oil reserves

  • provides the UK Treasury with one of its biggest single sources of revenue - whisky duty

  • produces 30% of branded PCs in Europe

  • is number 4 internationally for fund management

  • has almost half of its young people in full time post-school education (compared with only a third in the UK)

And that’s just for starters. We have some of the finest food and drink products and universities to rival the best in the world. We also have a globally recognised brand and identity and a worldwide reputation for integrity – key to our success in the 21st century knowledge economy.

Scotland’s problem is not a lack of resources, but that we are controlled by a London Government whose whole economic policy is designed for the needs of the south east of England economy, not focussed on the needs of Scotland.

Scotland is a wealthy country, but not a wealthy society. That’s because the wealth of Scotland is not used for the people of Scotland. And because we don’t control what happens to our own taxes.

As a result we are tied to the long-term relative economic decline of the UK. From 1st in the world wealth league at the turn of the 20th century, the UK is now only 19th and falling.

Scotland can more than afford Independence. Peter Woods, Senior Economist at Pieda said on 23-8-97, "There is no doubt that Scotland could be a relatively prosperous independent country". And Alf Young, Economics Editor of The Herald said on 18-1-97, "Personally I have never had any doubt that Scotland could survive and indeed prosper as an independent economy".

Indeed, the late Donald Dewar, Labour’s former First Minister, acknowledged Scotland’s potential: "Quite simply, I accept entirely that Scotland could sustain Independence. I accept entirely that Scotland can have Independence if it wants it." (BBC TV's Panorama 17-2-92)

What about claims Scotland would be in deficit?

New Labour’s claim that an independent Scotland would be in serious deficit are undermined by the fact that Scotland had a fiscal surplus in twelve of the last twenty years, whereas, on those same Government figures, the UK has only had a surplus in four of those twenty years. By their own logic this would mean the London parties should argue the UK can’t afford to be independent.

This is not a serious argument, it is a cynical attempt to spread fear, uncertainty and doubt.

If you take away the politics and anti-SNP propaganda and look at the bare economic facts, the black hole is in the UK’s fiscal position, not Scotland’s. Even if we look at the Government's own biased figures it is clear that Scotland will be in surplus by 2003. And Scotland’s surplus is just the starting point. It is economic growth that matters. More economic growth means more wealth creation and more revenue for Scottish public services.

But to do all that we need a Government responsive to the needs of the Scottish economy, with the economic powers to act in Scotland’s interests.

One of the most depressing things about the arguments used by the opponents of Independence is that they base their case on the outcomes of their own failed record and offer this as evidence that Scotland should not move on.

For example, Scotland’s non-oil growth rate between 1968 and 1998 averaged 2.1%, compared to 2.4% for the UK. If that gap had been filled our economy would be worth £6 billion more this year delivering £2.5 billion more tax revenues. The Republic of Ireland in recent years has averaged 10% a year. If Ireland can achieve this without the natural resources of Scotland, think what Scotland could achieve with Independence. We need policies to place us at a competitive advantage to the rest of the UK and the powers to deliver these policies lies only with Westminster at present. Scotland has it all in terms of potential, what we lack is the power to deliver.

Is Scotland subsidised by the UK?

The unionist argument that Scotland is subsidised is an odd one. Firstly, if it were true, it would hardly be an advert for the UK’s management of Scotland’s economy. This argument is essentially saying that Scotland has been made poor by London management so cannot afford to be independent. The logic of this suggests that we can’t afford not to be independent.

At any rate, the claim is a false one, and always has been. Throughout the 1990’s the Tory Government produced GERS figures - Government Expenditure and Revenues in Scotland figures - supposedly "proving" that Scotland was subsidised, - a Tory tactic Labour have embraced and kept since 1997 - and claimed that these were objective civil service assessments, made without the political interference of Ministers.

That claim was rather undermined in 1995, when a letter came to light from Conservative Scottish Secretary of State Ian Lang to the Prime Minister John Major and Chancellor Kenneth Clarke which stated, "The booklet I have had prepared and printed, setting out the details of the Government’s expenditure and revenue in Scotland, I judge that it is just what is needed at present in our campaign to maintain our initiative and undermine the other parties."

Scotland more than pays her way in the UK – in fact we are net contributors to the UK economy.

By the UK Government's own famous admission in 1997, Scotland paid £27 billion more in taxes to the UK between 1979 and 1995 than it received in Government expenditure.

And, in the period between 2000 and 2002, Scotland will have sent another £7.7 billion surplus to Westminster - almost another £1,500 for every man woman and child.

"The SNP has done all of us a service by scotching the Tory myth that we are subsidy junkies." (Daily Record Editorial 8-4-97).

"The SNP claims that the Scottish Office figures are distorted. The Party has a point". (The Economist Editorial 26-10-96)

"The Government provokes it [the subsidy argument] by the ill-considered way in which it tries to combat the case for devolution and independence by insisting that the financial cost of standing on our own two feet could not be borne because of the advantages provided by the UK Treasury. This line of argument is counter-productive and ought to be dropped." (The Herald Editorial18-1-97)

However the Unionists will always try to say that Scotland is subsidised by the rest of the UK and that Independence means increased taxes or spending cuts. But that is the usual anti-Scottish argument that we will always hear from parties who try to tell Scots they are too poor and too stupid to run their own country.

The old assumption that Scotland is subsidised, which was once accepted as fact, is now discredited. There is every reason to believe that an independent Scotland would flourish; indeed the question is, can we afford not to be independent?

Subsidised or not the real economic question is whether policy made in Scotland for Scotland will be better for our economy than policy made in London without any focus on Scottish conditions.

Doesn’t the Barnett formula mean Scots get more than their fair share of UK spending?

Anti-Independence commentators often talk about the Barnett formula, by which public spending is allocated to different parts of the UK, as evidence that Scotland gets a good deal.

In fact, the Barnett formula is designed to ensure that public spending goes up by less in Scotland than it does in the UK as a whole. For instance, a 10% increase in public expenditure on relevant English programmes will yield, via Barnett, only an 8.1% increase in the money which the Scottish Parliament is allocated to spend in those areas. That’s what is meant by the "Barnett Squeeze". Over the next three years, the Barnett Squeeze will mean that Scotland loses out on £2 billion in government spending increases. Devolution, which aimed to allow for divergence between the way government operates in Scotland and the rest of the UK, is in fact constrained by a formula which is designed to ensure a convergence in government spending.

Though the unionist parties are keen to talk about spending in Scotland, they are less keen to admit to what Scotland pays the UK Treasury every year. That’s why the Scottish Parliament should control all taxes raised in Scotland.

 Return to Talking Independence Index Page