Go to the home page of Electric Scotland Read about our terms and conditions for using te site and out privacy policy Gte our contact information here Find accommodation in Scotland Get information on Scottish agriculture and wildlife Find hundreds of historical articles about Scotland Beth's monthly publication about the Scots diaspora and genealogy Hundreds of online books for you to read Learn something about business in Scotland We have some 800 children's stories for you to read This is where you'll learn all about Scottish clans and families and their history Learn about Scottish culture and also our old Scots language A collection of material from a native Indian writer on Indian lore, poems, recipes and lots more This is Alastair's personal site with his travel journals and loads of pictures taken on his travels in Scotland and abroad Hundreds of biographies of famous Scots A weekly publication from the Scots Independent Newspaper on matters to do with Scottish independence This is where you can message with others on any topic you wish and interact in a social network Great place to get those great Scottish recipes We do need some relaxation from time to time so enjoy some of our online games This is our six volume gazetteer of Scotland Get advice and resources to help with your genealogy research Learn all about Scotland's famous Haggis Learn about prevntative health care from old Scottish texts This is where we've profiled some Highland Games in Scotland and around the world Explore historic places and castles in Scotland Tons of information on the history of Scotland and the Scots Looing for a wee humour or humor story then enjoy our great collection here Poems and stories from the pen of John Henderson and also many of his own dorric poems Lots of interesting material for kids and children of all ages A bit of a catch all for things that don't have there own menu Some music and radio programs for you to listen to and lots of great sheet music Get up to date Scottish news and find all the local newspaper and television stations This is where you can read Electric Scotland's weekly newsletter and read back copies We have thousands of pictures of Scotland and this page will lead you to them We have lots of poetry and stories sent in by visitors to the site Send a postcard to friends, family or colleagues Yes the Bible but so much more Learn about Scotland's famous bard Robert Burns Learn about the Scots who moved to Ulster and onto the world Scotland's official langiuage for several centuries wasn't gaelic but Scots! Learn about the famous Scottish and Highland regiments Some useful services like a roman numeral calculator and personal worth Here you will find our own shopping malls Looking for those old Scots songs then this is where you'll find them History of sports in Scotland Learn about tartan and use the tartan search engines Travel and Tourism in Scotland Some interesting Scottish trivia to baffle your friends with Fun videos that we've taken over the years A Scottish wedding guide Find out the last 100 items we've added to the site Learn about what Scots did in the world Learn about Scots in the USA Learn about Scots in Canada Learn about Scots in Australia Learn about Scots in India Learn about Scots in Germany Learn about Scots in France Learn about Scots in New Zealand

Check all the Clans that have DNA Projects. If your Clan is not in the list there's a way for it to be listed.Edinburgh and Scotland Accommodation, Bed & Breakfast, Self Catering, Guest Houses, Inns, Holiday Tourist AccommodationAn amazing collection of unique holiday cottages, castles and apartments, all over Scotland in truly amazing locations.A comprehensive holiday accommodation Index for Scotland

Click here to get a Printer Friendly Page
Scots Place Names
Buy MacSweens haggis and Grants tinned haggis online from the Scottish Haggis Store
Buy Scottish Hampers, Christmas Hampers, Corporate Food and Gift Hampers from The Scottish Store
Advertise on all 1000+ pages of the Flag in the Wind
Handmade Gifts

 

Scots Independent

The Flag in the Wind
Features - Talking Independence

 Scottish Flag

Home | About Us | Subscriptions | Archives | SNP | Ad Rates | Features | Adverts | Events | Links

1. Why Independence?

1.1 What is Scottish Independence and Independence in Europe?

Independence is full control by the people of Scotland over all their own affairs, apart from control in any areas where they have freely agreed to share power with others.

Independence means the people of Scotland acting through their own parliament and government under a constitution of their own, over which they have final authority. Independence will be brought about by the democratic choice of the people of Scotland, expressed through a referendum.

Independence in Europe means accepting the role and responsibilities of a Member State of the European Union, in which independent states have pooled certain of their sovereign rights for the common advantage. Sharing sovereignty in Europe in this way enhances Scotland’s sovereignty because it increases our influence. The SNP believes that Independence in Europe is the logical next step for Scotland to take on its road to becoming a normal, democratic, European nation, just like Denmark, Ireland or Luxembourg.

Scotland is an ancient nation, and its people have modern democratic rights. Independence is about controlling our own destiny for the benefit of all our people. Independence is normal for nations of Scotland’s size, and Independence is now necessary if Scotland is to achieve her potential in the world.

Independence will enable the people of Scotland to take control of their lives by taking control of how Scotland is governed and how our money is raised and spent, which we need to do if we are to make Scotland the prosperous, socially just place it should be.

Westminster and the London parties may oppose Independence, but ultimately it is the people of Scotland’s right to decide.

1.2 We already have our own Parliament in Scotland - why do we need Independence?

Devolution is a move in the right direction, and the SNP campaigned vigorously for a 'Yes Yes' vote in the 1997 referendum on the creation of the Scottish Parliament. However, devolution is not Independence.

The Scottish Parliament has made Scotland more democratic but, until Independence, it will be severely restricted in its powers. We should always remember that Westminster retains control over:

  • almost the whole of the taxation system
    That means Westminster still decides what you pay in income tax and VAT, and still receives the taxes paid by businesses in Scotland, including revenues from North Sea oil. Even using all the tax powers available to it, the Scottish Parliament only controls 5% of the taxes raised in Scotland.

  • the Scottish Parliament’s income
    It’s Westminster, not Scotland, which decides the overall budget that the Scottish Parliament gets to spend on services like health, education, and law and order.

  • social security and pensions
    The Scottish Parliament has no power to alter benefits or improve the state pension.

  • broadcasting
    Scottish broadcasting – including even Gaelic broadcasting – is still regulated in Whitehall, not Edinburgh.

  • Scotland’s relations with the EU and the rest of the world
    Scotland’s government has no voice in the world, and no place at Europe’s top table.

  • defence
    Scotland and her Parliament have no say on defence issues, including the future or deployment of Scottish regiments, or over the fact that we are used as a base for nuclear weapons.

The Scottish Parliament is restricted by the Scotland Act 1998 from legislating on all these subjects, and many more besides. For instance, the Scottish Parliament can regulate the teaching profession, but not vets, and it can legislate on roads, but not on most aspects of the railways. Most bizarrely of all, it is allowed to legislate on vitamins B and C, but not vitamins A, D or E!

It is Westminster which collects Scottish taxpayers’ money and then recycles some of it back to the Scottish Parliament to be spent on services in Scotland.

The Scottish Parliament has less power than practically any other legislative Parliament in Europe – devolved or independent – to decide how it raises its own income. Scotland has less control over its own affairs than Flanders, the Basque Country, or even the Isle of Man. In Scotland, Westminster still effectively decides what the Scottish Parliament’s budget will be for Scotland’s vital public services. Even a local authority like Edinburgh City Council is responsible for raising 27% of the revenue which it spends, but the Scottish Parliament has no such power. That means it operates with one hand effectively tied behind its back.

Jordi PujolOn a recent visit to Edinburgh, Jordi Pujol, the President of the devolved government of Catalonia observed how much less power Scotland had than Catalonia over taxation and spending. Mr Pujol said that the Scottish Parliament’s fiscal powers needed to be "more general" if it was to be in a position to improve the lives of Scots. (The Herald 10-7-01) Even the Scottish Parliament’s Presiding Officer, Sir David Steel has called for more financial independence: "This country is very low down the league of countries in terms of tax-raising powers. I actually believe the Scottish Parliament should try to acquire a little more fiscal responsibility for raising the money that it spends." (The Scotsman 06-06-01)

We already have the Parliament – now we need to complete its powers.

 Return to Talking Independence Index Page