|
CAMPAIGNING FOR SCOTLAND
(Owned, Edited and Printed in Scotland since November
1926)
"Promoting all that is best in Scottish
Nationalism and all that is best in Scotland."
Content of the Flag in the Wind Web Site is the copyright of the Scots
Independent Newspaper.
[
Issue 364 - 25th May 2007] |
 Compiled by Richard Thomson |
Lots of great information to
read and enjoy under our
Features Section:
Scots
Language | Scottish Food |
Dates in History |
Scot Wit and lots more
Power Play
The Hunterston 'B' nuclear
power station in Ayrshire has come back on-line, after being out of
commission for nearly a year. However, in reporting this, BBC Scotland has
just repeated the commonplace claim from the pro-nuclear lobby that nuclear
stations generate half of all Scotland's electricity.
This is nonsense, and so it can be proven. According to these Scottish
Executive/DTI figures, Scotland's total electricity output is 45,517 GWh. Of
this, nuclear accounts for 15,863 GWh, or just under 35% of total output. A
lot, but nothing like half of Scottish output. It's not even half of
Scotland's requirements, as you find if you delve further into the figures.
Of Scotland's total electricity output, just 32,068 GWh is consumed in
Scotland. Some 5,208 GWh is lost (mostly in transmission); while 8,034 GWh
is exported to England and Northern Ireland through the interconnectors.
Hunterston 'B' itself produces something like 7900 GWh, or just under 50% of
Scotland's total nuclear output (the remainder coming from Torness in East
Lothian). In other words, when Hunterston shut down, it would have been
enough to reduce exports to almost zero, unless the 'slack' was taken up by
excess capacity elsewhere. Scotland’s needs would still have been met quite
comfortably from our other power stations.
But common sense should tell us that if nuclear accounts for half our
requirements, and Hunterston accounts for half of our nuclear output (which
it does), then Hunterston alone would be responsible for meeting some 25% of
our needs. Therefore, the outage would have reduced Scotland's capacity to
just 75% of normal levels, which would have meant the nightmare of the
lights going out becoming a reality.
Did you notice that happening last year? Me neither. This 50% from nuclear
figure only holds if you assume that unlike every other form of generation
in Scotland, nothing is lost in transmission, and further that it's only
coal, hydro and wind power etc which we export.
Lies, damn lies and statistics, eh?
Wendy 'Ready To Run'
From Scotland on Sunday:
Another leading candidate for the post, should McConnell quit, is new
shadow justice secretary Margaret Curran. Speculation is growing within the
Labour Party that the two may sign up to a 'joint ticket'.
Both, however, are understood to want to dampen down speculation they will
challenge McConnell. A source close to [Wendy] Alexander added: "The person
who makes the wrong move at the wrong time will come unstuck, because they
will come across as disloyal."
Whoops... that'll be no marks for courage or for loyalty, then.
A Scottish Olympic
Team?
Not being one of life's
natural athletes, with the exception of football and occasionally rugby,
sport is something I find it hard to get too worked up about these days. I
go to the gym, I occasionally play football, I like to swim when I can find
the time, but nowadays life just seems to get in the way.
It's not that I don't admire the dedication of our athletes or their
physical prowess, it's just that, well, in general I'm not very interested.
Frankly, I'd rather go to the pub or read a book or stick on some music or
phone a friend. But for some reason, regardless as to the sport, my interest
level increases when it's a Scot that's competing.
There's nothing particularly logical or rational about it, it's just the way
it is. Consequently, a lifetime of complete indifference towards cricket
melted away when Scotland competed in this year's World Cup. Similarly, my
disdain for tennis in general and Wimbledon in particular disappeared when
Andy Murray came on the scene.
Suddenly, I started to see that men's tennis could be about much more than
simply hitting the ball as hard as you could. There was, or could be, an
artistry in there too, allowing brains to beat brawn. More interestingly, I
began to see that each point was about maneuvering your opponent into a
position where you could play your winning shot, while trying to get them to
run around so they would tire first. I saw subtlety where before I had seen
nothing but brute force. And if I were 13 instead of 30, I'd probably be out
on a tennis court right now, determined to be the next Andy Murray.
I'm racking my brains just now to think of any non-Scottish sports stars
that’ve ever had that same sort of effect on me when competing at national
level, and you know what? I'm really struggling. I used to be an alright
sprinter, but neither Carl Lewis nor Linford Christie did it for me in the
way that Alan Wells did. Steve Redgrave's achievements in rowing are beyond
compare, yet somehow I still feel more pride at the all-Scottish curling
team wining Olympic Gold. As I said, there's nothing logical or rational
about it. It's purely an emotional thing.
I was 10 when the Commonwealth Games last came to Edinburgh, and it inspired
all the kids in my street to get into badminton, bowling, running, cycling -
anything. It was happening in our city, in our country - there were friends
of friends of big brothers competing; people from your dad's bowling club in
the Scottish team - it was exciting, it was inspiring, and made all the more
so for us because the athletes were competing as a Scottish team.
Like I said, there's no logic or reason for why we should have felt that way
- it's just the way it was. In the 1980's, Steve Ovett and Sebastian Coe
might have had their titanic battles over the 800m crown, and Steve Cram
might have been the golden boy of distance running. However, it was Tom
McKean, Yvonne Murray and Liz Lynch as she then was, who got us putting on
our trainers and running round the park in our little corner of Edinburgh.
Does wearing a Scottish shirt put an extra spring in your step; a British
one make you run with the psychological effect of wearing divers' boots, or
vice versa? I don't know. What I do know is that you could make Morris
Dancing an Olympic Sport and I'd stay up till half 4 in the morning to watch
the Scottish team. However, while I'll sit glued to the 6 Nations playing
rugby, I'll switch over when the British Lions play, not because it offends
me as a Scottish nationalist (it doesn't), but because I just don't care.
There, I've said it. Go away and shoot me.
Individual talent is no respecter of national boundaries, and the best
talents train at the best facilities all round the world. That's why I find
the argument that athletes competing in a Scottish Olympic team would be
shut out from British facilities that we'd helped to pay for, such a bizarre
argument. Similarly, the idea that our athletes would win fewer medals than
they would as part of a UK team is utterly risible, epitomising all that's
worst about the 'awww, we're rubbish!', 'expect the worst and you'll never
be disappointed', loser mentality that stifles so much talent and potential
in Scotland.
Ultimately, the arguments for a British Olympic team hold the same force as
arguments to scrap the 'home' nations' football and rugby teams to allow us
to compete as a bigger entity. Shared facilities, no duplication of taxation
to pay for it all, everyone working as part of a team, the shared
camaraderie as we all come together as one, the pride in our collective
breast as our flag runs up the pole to the sound of 'God save the Queen'...
aye, right. There might be logic in there, somewhere, but even if there is
it still leaves me completely cold.
We rightly celebrate the individual talent, but what is it that inspires the
talent to reveal itself in the first place, or develops the enthusiasm for
sport which lasts a lifetime? If I and my friends from 20 years ago are
anything to go by, it's from seeing people just like you, who come from
places like you come from, competing and winning at the highest level. The
way to ensure that is probably a Scottish Olympic team, which everyone can
support, regardless as to their politics. But let's not fall out over it.
It's only sport, after all...
The Working Life of Linda
Fabiani MSP

Click here to read SNP MSP Linda Fabiani's working diary.
SYNOPSIS
First Minister Committed to
Lead in the Scottish National Interest
In his acceptance speech following the vote for First Minister of Scotland
in the Scottish Parliament, Alex Salmond committed himself to leadership
wholly and exclusively in the Scottish national interest.
Speaking to Parliament, Mr Salmond said:
"As we should remember, the Parliament was created by the people of Scotland
in a referendum. It is bigger than any of its members or any party. I
believe that Scotland is ready for change and ready for reform. We are a
small nation, but we have a big future. We also face some big challenges.
"Earlier on, it was said that Scotland is a divided nation. Given the
closeness of the election result, I understand why people might feel that
way. However, it is not the case; we are not divided. Certainly the gap
between rich and poor is far too great; we need to grow the economy faster;
we need to heal the scars of the past; we need to be greener; and we need to
be smarter still—but we are not divided. We have a sense of ourselves, a
sense of community and, above all, a sense of the commonweal of Scotland.
"In some ways, we are not even a divided Parliament. Of course, those in
this part of the chamber seek independence and equality for Scotland. I am
told that not everyone in the chamber agrees with that policy, although some
members do. However, there is a broad consensus for the Parliament to assume
greater responsibility for the governance of Scotland, as well as an
understanding that we are engaged in a process of self-government and an
awareness of the distance that we have already traveled.
"In 1961, Bashir Ahmad came to Glasgow to drive buses. In 1961, the very
idea of a Scottish Parliament was unimaginable. In 1961, the idea of a Scots
Asian sitting in a Scots Parliament was doubly unimaginable, but Bashir is
here and we are here. That part of the community of Scotland is now woven
into the Parliament's tartan and we are much stronger as a result. We are
therefore diverse, not divided.
"The nature and the composition of the Scottish Parliament in its third
session make it imperative for this Government to rely on the strength of
argument in the Parliament rather than on the argument of parliamentary
strength. Despite all the challenges that that will mean, I welcome the
chance to develop a new and fundamentally more reflective model of democracy
in Scotland.
"The days since the election have been dominated by questions about the
structure of the Government. Will there be a coalition or will there be a
minority Government? I say to the whole Parliament that the structure of the
Government matters less to the people whom we represent than what all of us
achieve on their behalf.
"All of us in the Parliament have a responsibility to conduct ourselves in a
way that respects the Parliament that the people have chosen to elect. That
will take patience, maturity and leadership on all sides of the chamber. My
pledge to the Parliament today is that any Scottish Government that is led
by me will respect and include the Parliament in the governance of Scotland
over the next four years.
"In this century, there are limits to what Governments can achieve, but one
thing that any Government that I lead will never lack is ambition for
Scotland. Today I commit myself to leadership wholly and exclusively in the
Scottish national interest. We will appeal for support across the chamber
policy by policy. That is the Parliament that the people of Scotland have
elected and that is the Government that I will be proud to lead."
It's Time for Scotland's Voice to be Heard in
Europe
SNP MEP Alyn Smith MEP has said that it's time for Scotland's voice to be
heard in Europe. The SNP MEP said that the SNP will give Scotland a stronger
and more effective voice by ensuring that there is better Scottish scrutiny
of EU legislation and an effective voice for Scottish interests in Brussels
to get the best deal for Scotland in Europe.
The SNP MEP made the call following a report published by the Scottish
Parliament's European and External Relations Committee stated that the
Scottish parliament should play a stronger role in the development of
European law.
Speaking from Brussels, Mr Smith said:
"I welcome this report and agree whole heartedly that the Scottish
Parliament must play a greater role in scrutinising EU legislation.
"On giving evidence to the Committee I called for regular discussions
between the Parliament and MEPs and a joint debate in Holyrood to ensure all
sides are working to shape the best possible laws for Scotland.
"It is clear from the leaked report from Michael Aron on the Executive's
performance in Europe that Scotland is losing out. Scotland needs a
government that is genuinely committed to getting the best deal for Scotland
in Europe, not doing as they are told by London.
"It seems ridiculous that Mr McConnell is in Brussels today to promote
Scotland as an example of strong communication when back home his
Executive's own reports show that they have repeatedly failed to ensure
there are sufficient channels of communication between Scotland and Europe.
"An SNP government at Holyrood with a dedicated Minister for European and
External Relations will work with the Parliament to build Scottish scrutiny
of EU legislation and ensure Scotland's voice is heard loud and clear in the
EU."
Post Office Closures: "Death by a Thousand
Cuts"
SNP Trade and Industry Spokesperson, Mike Weir MP has expressed his great
disappointment and concern in reaction to Thursday’s Ministerial statement
on Post Office closures.
Trade and Industry Secretary, Alistair Darling confirmed the closure of a
further 2,500 post offices by 2009 on top of the 4,000 already shut down in
the past eight years. Overall, this amounts to one fifth of the UK's post
office network.
Speaking after the statement Mr Weir said:
"The Post Office remains essential to Scotland's rural communities. This
statement merely confirms that the network will suffer death by a thousand
cuts.
"There remains no detail of which Post Offices will close. The agony for
many communities goes on. The only glimmer of hope is that the government
has belatedly accepted the need to include the impact on local economies,
something the SNP have long pressed for.
"The government needs to make it absolutely clear how the area proposals
will work in Scotland. In rural areas we could be talking about massive
areas."
|