LATIN TAGS
Last
week I had an email from a lady in Queensland Australia, asking
about Scotland’s emblem; apparently there was some confusion among
her friends as to whether it was the Thistle or the Bluebell.
When I
responded with the Thistle, I also commented that Scotland’s motto
was "Nemo me impune lacessit", translated as "Wha daur meddle wi’
me?" This then set me thinking as to what was the motto of our new
Parliament? I looked on their website, and I suppose it must be
there somewhere, but as to where I wouldn’t know.
However, one thing
I do know; it cannot be "Nemo me impune lacessit", because the
Executive, as distinct from the Parliament, seem to be prepared to
take instructions and orders from all and sundry, with the
Westminster Parliament leading the charge. Of course, we are led
by the Lib-Flab alliance, who all believe in the Great God of
London. Just think how many Sewel motions have been passed by this
motley crew; anything remotely controversial - let London decide.
It was always
presumed that any legislature would seek to accrue more powers to
itself, but that has not happened with this Scottish Executive. In
consequence, I think the appropriate motto for them should be
"Ultra Vires." This means that things are beyond their powers, and
they are doing their damnedest to put as much beyond their powers
as they can.
SPRING IN THE
AIR
I
went to the SNP Spring Conference in Aberdeen on Saturday last. As
is my wont, I did not go to hear speeches and motions, but to see
people and get the feel of what is going on. (As a non-delegate, I
can do as I please.) The Conference, which was about rewriting the
SNP Constitution, had been forecast as yet another trial for what
the meejah refered to as the "beleaguered leader of the SNP, John
Swinney". You wouldn’t think so!
What the
meejah, and the coterie comprising the now suspended MSP Campbell
Martin and his acolytes (and puppetmasters) do not seem to
understand is that the Party likes and trusts John Swinney; there
was an exasperated reaction from the assembled delegates of "We
elected John Swinney in September last year, we are now in the
middle of another election campaign, so would you all get off our
backs." And of course, all John’s proposals for the new
constitution went through; I personally did not agree with one
proposal, the one on gender balance, but it is in there now.
According to one doubter, her view was swung by Nicola Sturgeon’s
comment on the Labour women numpties in Holyrood. She asked "Have
you looked at the Labour men numpties?" Touche - as they say in
Govan.
I enjoyed John
Swinney’s speech; in it he paid tribute to Neil MacCormick, who
retires from the European Parliament this year. He praised Neil’s
contribution to Scotland over the years, and in true SNP fashion
said that while Neil was perhaps retiring from the European
Parliament, he would not be allowed to retire from the SNP! John’s
speech can be seen in full at
www.snp.org, but two things in particular are worth
highlighting, in my view. In the first place, he very astutely
laid out the terms for SNP support for a referendum on the
European Constitution. The message to Mr Blair is simple; if you
want our support make the repatriation of fishing a red line
issue. This puts us on solid ground ( North Sea mixed metaphors
notwithstanding); fishing is a major Scottish industry, and unless
it is returned to British control, initially, we will not support
the European Constitution. A few things flow from this; first it
gives Labour the chance to recover an asset the Tories gave away
as "of no material benefit", and secondly it has the Labour Party
split between those who toe the current party line, and the
pragmatists. An instance of this was on BBC TV on Sunday and an
exchange between Alex Salmond MP and Anne MacGuire, Scottish
Office Minister; Ms MacGuire said that leaving the Common
Fisheries Policy was not government policy. Alex rather cruelly
remarked that a referendum on the European Constitution had not
been government policy either, until that week! Of course, a "No"
vote in the referendum could presage the United Kingdom leaving
the European Community, giving rise to "And whaur’s your Common
Fisheries Policy noo?" All good stuff.
Secondly, John has
never struck me as being lyrical, or particularly emotional, but
in his summing up of the power of the Independence culture, he
said:
"It is the power to
contribute. The power to compete. To create wealth. To care for
the vulnerable.
"To live and
breathe every day the sweet air of liberation."
SNP
INTERNATIONAL
The
Conference was also addressed by a member of the Irish Cabinet,
Pat the Cope Gallagher TD, Minister for the Environment and Local
Government, who brought fraternal greetings from Bertie Ahern, the
Taosieach, and Fianna Fail. I may have missed something over the
years, but an address from a Government Minister of another EU
member state is quite significant.
I was intrigued by
the name "Pat the Cope", but it is not a nickname; according to
one BBC reporter it was because his grandfather had introduced
co-operative societies into Ireland. He was known as "Pat the
Cope", and it was incorporated into the family name. (When I lived
in Peterhead I remember two people called MacDonald, one who was
the manager for the bus company and one who was a bank manager;
they were known as "MacDonald the Bus" and "MacDonald the Bank."
However, their names were not incorporated.)
Minister Gallagher
had served in the European Parliament and had a warm and friendly
working relationship with Winnie Ewing, and also with the late Dr
Allan MacCartney, and Neil MacCormick and Ian Hudghton; proof
positive that alliances can be formed in the European context.
Conference was also
addressed by a member of the Georgian Parliament, who quoted from
the Declaration of Arbroath, as evidence that the people from his
country and Scotland were related! He quoted "..the Scots had
journeyed from Greater Scythia by way of the Tyrrhenian Sea and
the Pillars of Hercules, and after many years among the savage
tribes of Spain had come to this land." Georgia is on the Black
Sea, and Scythia ran from there to perhaps Archangel, as far as I
can establish. (One thing about SNP Conferences; they get me
poring over both modern and historical atlases, trying to
co-relate the ancient and modern worlds!)
The gist of the
speech by our Georgian friend, whose name escaped me, but who I
now know was Ziav Mukbianani, was that of all the political
parties in the United Kingdom, the SNP had been the most helpful
to his nation. This was a reference to the Peace talks held last
December in Craigellachie (he got a cheer for his pronounciation),
and organised by Angus Robertson SNP MP for Moray; the talks
involved delegates from Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia, and
Scotland was the neutral venue. The talks were the first time the
countries had sat down together, and I understand the events even
included a football match with the three countries taking on
Scotland, and no, I don’t know the result, and I don’t want to
know it.
THE COPYCAT -
AGAIN
When
I emailed Helen Graham of Bridge of Allan & Logie Branch to tell
her I was pinching their idea for press releases, her response was
that she didn’t believe in re-inventing the wheel! Anyway, I find
their newsletter of great value, so here is another bit I have
pinched from this month’s!
Seriously Funny!
A quiz raising more
questions than answers.
Q1; Which Party, in
London, says it is against the commercial growing of GM crops -
but, in Scotland, accepts it should go ahead?
Q2: Which Party is
in favour of congestion charging in cities - while arguing against
it in Edinburgh council elections?
Q3: Which Party
questions anti-social behaviour orders - but called for tougher
action on youth crime in recent Westminster by-elections?
Q4: Which Party’s
non-Executive MSPs backed the Airborne rehabilitation project -
but failed to support an SNP motion to give it a stay of
execution?
Q5: Which Party
supports the Common Fisheries Policy - yet condones one of its
Ministers telling constituents he wants it scrapped?
Answer: Did you
realise how often the Lib-Dems try to have it both ways?
GEOGRAPHY 0 -
HISTORY 0
The
recent rumpus sparked off by the Labour Party regarding Scotland’s
right to remain in the European Union after Independence requires
a bit of explanation; the issue was highlighted by a Scottish
Labour MEP somewhere about mid April, and the answer given by
Romano Prodi was hailed by Labour as a definitive answer - we were
out, and would have to re-apply! At the time I was under the
impression that Mr Prodi was talking about Italy, and safeguarding
against any moves there.
A little
research produces a degree of clarity that Labour might find
embarrassing; the question was asked on 12th February 2004 by a
Welsh Labour MEP, Elunud Morgan. Mr Prodi was asked about Algeria,
and the question was answered on 1st March 2004; quite why it took
so long for Labour,( mid April), to shout the answer from the
rooftops is unclear. Quite why a Welsh MEP asked about Algeria,
which is in Africa, and was a French colony, wanting to join the
European Community is also unclear; perhaps Labour politicians are
not aware that Algeria is on the other side of the Mediterranean?
Also, if there was concern about former colonies, why not, for
instance, Kenya, which is a former British colony, as I know, for
I was there? Anyway, a vague question regarding Africa was asked
by a Welsh Labour MEP, then publicised by a Scottish Labour MEP,
and there are rumours that Mr Prodi is horrified at the slant put
on his answer.
However, a more
authoritative answer, to the correct question, came from Eamonn
Gallagher; Mr Gallagher was born in Glasgow, and is an Irish
citizen now living in Brussels. During his career, he was the
European Community’s Ambassador to the United Nations, and the
Director General of the European Commission. His statement is as
follows:
"Assuming Scottish
independence by agreed constitutional change in the United
Kingdom, both new entities, Scotland and the rest of the United
Kingdom, would be equally entitled to continue their existing full
membership of the European Union. There is, and in my view could
be, no sustainable legal or political objection to this shared
"right of succession". Thus the case of Scotland is specific and
distinctive in law, and cannot be addressed accurately by general
answers, or those that are premised on the example of other
places. It would be politically absurd to attempt to use such
answers to discuss the particular case of an independent
Scotland."
John Swinney, SNP
leader, who was taking part in an SNP/Plaid Cymru EU enlargement
summit, commented "As part of a concereted campaign of
misinformation by Labour MEPs, Mr Prodi was asked a question about
Algeria- and his answer was not about Scotland! Therefore it is
irrelevant to the Scottish debate."
As to the headline,
Algeria is in Africa, and an independent Scotland signed a Treaty
of Union with England, and is not a colony, however much the
Labour Party like to regard it as such.
POLICY POSTCARDS
We
continue our publication of the SNP Policy Postcards; we will
publish a new one every week, each one dealing with a different
aspect of SNP policy. The full list can be seen on the SNP website
under "Vision" and "Policy".
Better off
British? Funding
Anybody who
believes that the UK does a good job of representing Scotland’s
interests in Europe should reflect on the fact that the Highlands
and Islands have lost potentially hundreds of millions of pounds
in EU funds because the UK Office of National Statistics got their
sums wrong.
The Highlands and
Islands should have qualified for Objective One status—but the
Office of National Statistics used out of date figures, leading to
the region losing out on EU money they were entitled to.
The Government
was repeatedly told that they had got their sums wrong—but
paid no attention.
It is
inconceivable that an independent Scottish government of any
political complexion would have made such a mistake.
Scotland needs
a political leadership that puts the needs of Scotland first
and is focused on making the EU work for us, not against us.
Only the SNP can be trusted to do that.
FOOT IN
THE MOUTH NOTES
Last
week Concorde arrived at the Museum of Flight in East Fortune,
East Lothian after a week long journey by barge and special
trailer, costing some £350,000 in total, the journey, that was. A
few weeks back I wondered why they had not left it at Edinburgh
Airport when it called in there in the autumn?
The answer is
that we got the broken one that couldn’t fly anywhere.
Last week there was
a picture in the Scotsman of the Justice Minister, Cathy
Jamieson,confidently striding up to the Parliament, ready to face
down all the critics of the contract awarded to Reliance Custodial
Services, who seemed to have coined a new phrase; we have all
heard of the offence "Wrongful arrest", but the new one is
"Wrongful release."
Parked on
double yellow lines beside the smiling minister, was a taxi; the
notice on its door said "Open doors for yourself." How quaint.
Apparently
the English Home Secretary has agreed that Muslim women will be
exempt from having their photographs on the new identity cards
which are to be forced on all of us; the Muslim Council of Britain
are concerned that the identity cards may be used to persecute
ethnic minorities.
One wonders how
they manage passports?
On my return from
the Spring Conference, I watched the televised parts which my wife
had helpfully taped in my absence, particularly as I am not prone
to spending a lot of time in the Conference itself. I was struck
by the very knowledgeable way in which the BBC Westminster
correspondent, David Porter previewed what he thought John Swinney
would or would not say in his Conference address. His "assessment"
was remarkably astute.
And then I
wondered? Did he, like myself, have a copy of John’s speech,
headed by "Check against delivery"? Another illusion shattered!
Diversification
is often seen as the most logical solution for ailing companies,
but I sometimes wonder?
Headline in the
Business Herald this week; "Scottish Coal planning £36 million
wind farm."
Mr Blair, the
current British Prime Minister, has brushed off the open letter
from over 50 retired British diplomats, who all believed that his
enthusiam for tying foreign policy to that of the United States
was disastrous. In his response he said the letter was from
"private citizens who were not grasping the full complexity of the
situation in Iraq and between Israel and Palestine."
Unlike George
Bush, of course.
DON’T PAY NEW
LABOUR
Back
yet again to one of my hobby horses. It has long been my belief
that most people who pay the political levy to the Labour Party do
so because it is difficult to stop it. This form was supplied to
Peter D Wright by the SNP Trade Union Group at the SNP Spring
Conference in Aberdeen last weekend, but despite my best
machinations via my scanner and trying to download it from the TUG
site, I had to enter it by hand! For further information and help
go to www.snptug.org
POLITICAL FUND (EXEMPTION
NOTICE)
I hereby give
notice that I object to contribute to the political fund of the
Union, and am in consequence exempt, in the manner provided by
Chapter VI of Part 1 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations
(Consolidation) Act 1992 from contributing to that fund.
Name:
Address:
Postcode:
__________________________________________________________________________
Name of Branch:
Union Membership
Number:
___________________________________________________________________________
Name of Employer:
Workplace Address:
Postcode:
Payroll number:
___________________________________________________________________________
Signature:
Date:
___________________________________________________________________________
SYNOPSIS
Although all our
Parliamentarians were at the Spring Conference in Aberdeen, they
all found time to attend to Parliamentary business; slight
correction, one MSP, Campbell Martin MSP, was unable to attend the
Conference, but did manage to give press, radio and TV interviews.
We are unable to cover them as his conduct is now sub judice.
Following
a vote in the House of Commons on an amendment to the Finance Bill
to delete the imposition if fraud-prone tax stamps on bottles of
Scotch whisky - which was defeated by 298 to 186 - the SNP MP for
Moray Mr Angus Robertson said:
"Whisky tax stamps
are opposed by the industry, unions, and the Scotch Whisky
Association, who proposed sensible alternative anti-fraud
measures. The National Audit Office criticised the Customs &
Excise figures that were used to justify tax stamps."
Central
Scotland MSP Linda Fabiani said MSPs should discuss ID cards at
Holyrood as the English Home Secretary David Blunkett published
his draft legislation on the subject at Westminster and it was
revealed that Glasgow will be one of the pilot areas.
Ms Fabiani told BBC
Radio Scotland's Good Morning Scotland programme: "When it's
something as fundamentally important to everybody in Scotland,
everybody has the right for it to be discussed in Parliament".
The draft Bill was
being published at Westminster as trials involving 10,000
volunteers got under way to test the technology that could make
the scheme a reality.
Angus
MP Mike Weir has challenged the government over the continuing
spate of Post Office closures and said that the policy of direct
payment of benefits was to blame for many of the closures.
Speaking during
Department of Work and Pensions questions in the Commons Mr. Weir
pointed out that many post offices closed because of a loss of
benefits business and asked the minister
"How many more Post
Offices does he expect to close should be manage to strong-arm the
remaining pension and benefit claimants who have not yet
transferred to opt for direct payment?"
Mr. Weir said that
the minister's reply where he claimed the government were
strengthening the network was "complete fantasy".
The
general public are being overcharged for water rates by a
staggering 300 million pounds is the conclusion of the dissenting
minority report into the finances of Scottish Water published on
Friday 23rd April 2004 by Jim Mather MSP, John Swinburne MSP and
Fergus Ewing MSP.
The MSPs, all
members of the Scottish Parliament’s Finance Committee, concluded:
there have been
serious mistakes in the management of the financial control of
the water industry
the revenue
caps recommended in the review are too high, by a significant
margin
the amount of
capital investment, which was planned to be funded from
borrowing, was too low.
charges for
water users in Scotland have been set too high, most probably
by at least £300 million cumulatively over the period 2002-06
In a joint
statement, the MSPs said:
"The view taken by
the majority of the Finance Committee, and reflected in the
Majority report, does not accurately reflect the evidence, which
has been presented to the Committee nor, the errors which were
made in financial control both by the Scottish Executive and the
Water Industry Commissioner."
When
speaking to the Scottish Occupational Health Nurses’ Forum annual
conference Shadow Health Minister Ms Shona Robison MSP adddressed
the issue of attacks on health workers in the workplace.
"Stress has become
a major health problem, with it being estimated that work-related
stress cost Scotland about 370 million pounds every year, and it
is therefore in our best interests to tackle this problem.
"Violence and aggression are other serious problems in the
workplace that must be tackled. I firmly believe that attacks on
any staff should be treated under the law as serious assaults;
workers anywhere should not have to be concerned about violence
and aggression and any new legislation should reflect this."
Shadow
Tourism Minister Mr Kenny MacAskill MSP has launched a paper which
revealed that Tourism Ireland is outspending VisitScotland by a
massive nine million pounds in marketing in Europe and North
America.
Together, Europe and North America make up three quarters of
Scotland's overseas tourism market. In March, tourism minister
Frank McAveety announced an extra five million pounds for
marketing Scotland, yet Ireland still significantly outspends
Scotland in these two crucial markets. Commenting, Mr MacAskill
said:
"Tourism is Scotland's biggest industry, with a fantastic product
to sell but insufficient resources to properly do so. For the
Executive to be slapping themselves on the back for an increase in
the marketing budget while our main rivals out spend us by nine
million pounds in our two most vital overseas markets is beyond
belief."
Shadow
Enterprise and Economy Minister Mr Jim Mather MSP has called for
greater economic powers and more economic data following the
publication of the Quarterly Growth Data for the fourth quarter of
2003 by the Scottish Executive, which shows that the rest of the
UK is growing at 4 times the rate of Scotland. Commenting on the
figures, Mr Mather said:
"Alongside Wales and Northern Ireland, Scotland still has no
power to run its own economy and has no target for economic
growth.
"Andy Kerr said at yesterday's Finance Committee that the Scottish
Executive could not set targets in areas where they do not have
the levers to control the outcome. This should trigger more
widespread concern because he was amazingly unconcerned about this
powerless situation."